Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles

Joel M H Teichman, Monte S. Dirks, Anthony J. Johnson, Joel T. Muirhead, Ian M. Thompson, Margaret S. Pearle

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Lasers are often used in intracorporeal endoscopic lithotripsy. However, lasers may expose the urologist to hazardous laser energy that may injure the macula and fovea. To avoid ocular injury, laser safety goggles are worn. Each goggle is tinted which imparts color distortion. However, it is axiomatic that normal vision of the urologist enhances ease and safety of surgery. This study tested color discrimination among urologists using different goggles, and assessed and quantified visual impairment. Consecutive subjects (urologists) underwent a Farnsworth Dichotomous Test for Color Blindness (D-15), a standardized screening test of color blindness where subjects match equal hue steps in the natural color circle. Subjects then underwent a Farnsworth-Munsell (FM) 100-hue test to measure areas of color confusion. Subjects were tested without goggles (control), and with goggles for coumarin green, Alexandrite, and HoTmiumiYAG. Subjects were also asked to rate which matching color sets were problematic to differentiate for each set of goggles. Statisical analysis was done with chi-square for the D-15, and t-test on Aspinall's square root transformation of the error score for the FM. All 15 subjects tested within normal limits on the D-15 and FM tests without goggles and with Holmium:YAG goggles. On the D-15, subjects had % errors (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, CO2, and Alexandrite goggles of 43110, 2±0, andO±0, respectively (p<0.01). On the more sensitive FM test, the error scores (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, Alexandrite, Holmium:YAG, and control (no goggles) were 319 ±69, 91 ±32, 20 ±12, and 20 ±14, respectively (p<0.05). The difficult color matches were consistent for all subjects: (1) coumarin green both blue-green and lavender; (2) Alexandrite both bluegreen and lavender; and (3) HolmiumiYAG none. The data shows that coumarin green safety goggles impair color vision and discrimination more than the Alexandrite or Holmium:YAG goggles. Holmium:YAG goggles impair color vision and discrimination the least and provide the most natural color vision among goggles tested. These results suggest that surgical vision is least affected by safety goggles for Holmium:YAG.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)342
Number of pages1
JournalBritish Journal of Urology
Volume80
Issue numberSUPPL. 2
StatePublished - 1997
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Eye Protective Devices
Color Vision Defects
Lasers
Safety
Holmium
Color
Color Vision
Lavandula
Urologists
Eye Injuries
Lithotripsy
Vision Disorders

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Urology

Cite this

Teichman, J. M. H., Dirks, M. S., Johnson, A. J., Muirhead, J. T., Thompson, I. M., & Pearle, M. S. (1997). Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles. British Journal of Urology, 80(SUPPL. 2), 342.

Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles. / Teichman, Joel M H; Dirks, Monte S.; Johnson, Anthony J.; Muirhead, Joel T.; Thompson, Ian M.; Pearle, Margaret S.

In: British Journal of Urology, Vol. 80, No. SUPPL. 2, 1997, p. 342.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Teichman, JMH, Dirks, MS, Johnson, AJ, Muirhead, JT, Thompson, IM & Pearle, MS 1997, 'Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles', British Journal of Urology, vol. 80, no. SUPPL. 2, pp. 342.
Teichman JMH, Dirks MS, Johnson AJ, Muirhead JT, Thompson IM, Pearle MS. Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles. British Journal of Urology. 1997;80(SUPPL. 2):342.
Teichman, Joel M H ; Dirks, Monte S. ; Johnson, Anthony J. ; Muirhead, Joel T. ; Thompson, Ian M. ; Pearle, Margaret S. / Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles. In: British Journal of Urology. 1997 ; Vol. 80, No. SUPPL. 2. pp. 342.
@article{024bad1e4f05469abc9c0c47ae26c624,
title = "Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles",
abstract = "Lasers are often used in intracorporeal endoscopic lithotripsy. However, lasers may expose the urologist to hazardous laser energy that may injure the macula and fovea. To avoid ocular injury, laser safety goggles are worn. Each goggle is tinted which imparts color distortion. However, it is axiomatic that normal vision of the urologist enhances ease and safety of surgery. This study tested color discrimination among urologists using different goggles, and assessed and quantified visual impairment. Consecutive subjects (urologists) underwent a Farnsworth Dichotomous Test for Color Blindness (D-15), a standardized screening test of color blindness where subjects match equal hue steps in the natural color circle. Subjects then underwent a Farnsworth-Munsell (FM) 100-hue test to measure areas of color confusion. Subjects were tested without goggles (control), and with goggles for coumarin green, Alexandrite, and HoTmiumiYAG. Subjects were also asked to rate which matching color sets were problematic to differentiate for each set of goggles. Statisical analysis was done with chi-square for the D-15, and t-test on Aspinall's square root transformation of the error score for the FM. All 15 subjects tested within normal limits on the D-15 and FM tests without goggles and with Holmium:YAG goggles. On the D-15, subjects had {\%} errors (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, CO2, and Alexandrite goggles of 43110, 2±0, andO±0, respectively (p<0.01). On the more sensitive FM test, the error scores (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, Alexandrite, Holmium:YAG, and control (no goggles) were 319 ±69, 91 ±32, 20 ±12, and 20 ±14, respectively (p<0.05). The difficult color matches were consistent for all subjects: (1) coumarin green both blue-green and lavender; (2) Alexandrite both bluegreen and lavender; and (3) HolmiumiYAG none. The data shows that coumarin green safety goggles impair color vision and discrimination more than the Alexandrite or Holmium:YAG goggles. Holmium:YAG goggles impair color vision and discrimination the least and provide the most natural color vision among goggles tested. These results suggest that surgical vision is least affected by safety goggles for Holmium:YAG.",
author = "Teichman, {Joel M H} and Dirks, {Monte S.} and Johnson, {Anthony J.} and Muirhead, {Joel T.} and Thompson, {Ian M.} and Pearle, {Margaret S.}",
year = "1997",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "80",
pages = "342",
journal = "BJU International",
issn = "1464-4096",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "SUPPL. 2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Urologist's visual color blindness caused by laser safety goggles

AU - Teichman, Joel M H

AU - Dirks, Monte S.

AU - Johnson, Anthony J.

AU - Muirhead, Joel T.

AU - Thompson, Ian M.

AU - Pearle, Margaret S.

PY - 1997

Y1 - 1997

N2 - Lasers are often used in intracorporeal endoscopic lithotripsy. However, lasers may expose the urologist to hazardous laser energy that may injure the macula and fovea. To avoid ocular injury, laser safety goggles are worn. Each goggle is tinted which imparts color distortion. However, it is axiomatic that normal vision of the urologist enhances ease and safety of surgery. This study tested color discrimination among urologists using different goggles, and assessed and quantified visual impairment. Consecutive subjects (urologists) underwent a Farnsworth Dichotomous Test for Color Blindness (D-15), a standardized screening test of color blindness where subjects match equal hue steps in the natural color circle. Subjects then underwent a Farnsworth-Munsell (FM) 100-hue test to measure areas of color confusion. Subjects were tested without goggles (control), and with goggles for coumarin green, Alexandrite, and HoTmiumiYAG. Subjects were also asked to rate which matching color sets were problematic to differentiate for each set of goggles. Statisical analysis was done with chi-square for the D-15, and t-test on Aspinall's square root transformation of the error score for the FM. All 15 subjects tested within normal limits on the D-15 and FM tests without goggles and with Holmium:YAG goggles. On the D-15, subjects had % errors (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, CO2, and Alexandrite goggles of 43110, 2±0, andO±0, respectively (p<0.01). On the more sensitive FM test, the error scores (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, Alexandrite, Holmium:YAG, and control (no goggles) were 319 ±69, 91 ±32, 20 ±12, and 20 ±14, respectively (p<0.05). The difficult color matches were consistent for all subjects: (1) coumarin green both blue-green and lavender; (2) Alexandrite both bluegreen and lavender; and (3) HolmiumiYAG none. The data shows that coumarin green safety goggles impair color vision and discrimination more than the Alexandrite or Holmium:YAG goggles. Holmium:YAG goggles impair color vision and discrimination the least and provide the most natural color vision among goggles tested. These results suggest that surgical vision is least affected by safety goggles for Holmium:YAG.

AB - Lasers are often used in intracorporeal endoscopic lithotripsy. However, lasers may expose the urologist to hazardous laser energy that may injure the macula and fovea. To avoid ocular injury, laser safety goggles are worn. Each goggle is tinted which imparts color distortion. However, it is axiomatic that normal vision of the urologist enhances ease and safety of surgery. This study tested color discrimination among urologists using different goggles, and assessed and quantified visual impairment. Consecutive subjects (urologists) underwent a Farnsworth Dichotomous Test for Color Blindness (D-15), a standardized screening test of color blindness where subjects match equal hue steps in the natural color circle. Subjects then underwent a Farnsworth-Munsell (FM) 100-hue test to measure areas of color confusion. Subjects were tested without goggles (control), and with goggles for coumarin green, Alexandrite, and HoTmiumiYAG. Subjects were also asked to rate which matching color sets were problematic to differentiate for each set of goggles. Statisical analysis was done with chi-square for the D-15, and t-test on Aspinall's square root transformation of the error score for the FM. All 15 subjects tested within normal limits on the D-15 and FM tests without goggles and with Holmium:YAG goggles. On the D-15, subjects had % errors (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, CO2, and Alexandrite goggles of 43110, 2±0, andO±0, respectively (p<0.01). On the more sensitive FM test, the error scores (mean ±standard deviation) for coumarin green, Alexandrite, Holmium:YAG, and control (no goggles) were 319 ±69, 91 ±32, 20 ±12, and 20 ±14, respectively (p<0.05). The difficult color matches were consistent for all subjects: (1) coumarin green both blue-green and lavender; (2) Alexandrite both bluegreen and lavender; and (3) HolmiumiYAG none. The data shows that coumarin green safety goggles impair color vision and discrimination more than the Alexandrite or Holmium:YAG goggles. Holmium:YAG goggles impair color vision and discrimination the least and provide the most natural color vision among goggles tested. These results suggest that surgical vision is least affected by safety goggles for Holmium:YAG.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33749300312&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=33749300312&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 80

SP - 342

JO - BJU International

JF - BJU International

SN - 1464-4096

IS - SUPPL. 2

ER -