Syme Amputation for Limb Salvage: Early Experience with 26 Cases

The Syme amputation is often overlooked as an alternative to below-knee amputation or above-knee amputation in cases of limb-threatening foot infections and gangrene. Even though the advantages of the Syme amputation over major amputation are well cited in the literature, many surgeons do not view this amputation as a viable option for limb salvage. We herein present our initial experience with this operation in a series of patients at imminent risk for major lower extremity amputation. This study included our initial 26 patients at high risk (92% had diabetes) with infection and/or significant peripheral arterial disease who underwent ankle disarticulation for limb salvage. Medical records were abstracted for pertinent demographic and clinical data. Variables of interest included diabetes status and duration, presence of peripheral arterial disease, infection, osteomyelitis, and gangrene. Our primary outcome variable was a healed amputation, whereas secondary outcomes included time to healing, subsequent major amputations, and complications. Despite prior recommendation for below-knee amputation or above-knee amputation in each of these patients, 50% remained healed at an average of 49.3 weeks of follow-up. Although 17 patients (65.4%) ambulated in a Syme prosthesis after healing of the original Syme operation, several patients went on to major amputation for progressive sepsis or recurrent ulcers, and 1 patient subsequently died. Because of the relatively small number of study subjects, we could find no significant predictors of success or failure of this procedure. However, all 10 patients eventually succumbing to major amputation and all 3 patients who died during follow-up had diabetes mellitus. At the end of follow-up, 46.2% (12/26) patients were functioning well in a Syme prosthesis. In this high-risk cohort of patients in whom major amputation had been recommended, we achieved a healing rate of 50% at an approximate 1-year follow-up. With the majority of patients having diabetes and peripheral vascular disease, we could not find any clear predictive factors for failure or successful outcome in this small population. Nonetheless, the Syme amputation deserves further study and consideration as a viable limb salvage option in patients threatened with major lower extremity amputation.