SU‐FF‐T‐102: Application of the Quality Index Methodology for Dosimetric Verification of Build‐Up Effect Beyond Air‐Tissue Interface in Treatment Planning System Algorithms

S. Caneva, M. Tsiakalos, Sotirios Stathakis, S. Zefkili, A. Mazal, J. Rosenwald

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose: We have developed and applied a methodology based on quality index (QI) to assess the accuracy of calculations performed on a number of commercial treatment planning systems (TPS) for the case of build‐up effect beyond air‐tissue interfaces. This methodology requires the preliminary constitution of a “reference data set”, obtained experimentally, where correction factors (CF) were calculated as the ratios of the ionization at a depth d beyond the air‐tissue interface to the ionization at the same geometrical point for the reference configuration and for the same number of monitor units. Material and Methods: CFs were obtained from measurements in a phantom that consisted of polystyrene slabs with a 10 cm air‐gap between them. Measurements were performed with a plane parallel ionization chamber at different depths beyond the distal air‐polystyrene interface. They have been repeated with and without the air‐gap at constant source‐detector distance, for a 5×5 cm2 field and for photon energies ranging from 4MV to 23MV and the respective Monte Carlo calculations have been performed the same phantom set‐up. Results: A number of commercial TPS algorithms were tested: users computed CF using basic beam data from their accelerators and these were compared to reference CF for the corresponding QI. Considering that the error in the determination of CF for all beam energies tested should not exceed 6%, at the tested depths only one algorithm calculated CF within this error. The rest of the algorithms overestimated or underestimated CF in the build‐up region. At depth where electronic equilibrium is achieved, results were acceptable for all algorithms. Conclusions: A test that can be easily performed has been designed to validate the calculation algorithm of a TPS for the build‐up effect, using the QI of the incident beam.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)2072
Number of pages1
JournalMedical Physics
Volume33
Issue number6
DOIs
StatePublished - 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Polystyrenes
Constitution and Bylaws
Photons
Datasets

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biophysics
  • Radiology Nuclear Medicine and imaging

Cite this

SU‐FF‐T‐102 : Application of the Quality Index Methodology for Dosimetric Verification of Build‐Up Effect Beyond Air‐Tissue Interface in Treatment Planning System Algorithms. / Caneva, S.; Tsiakalos, M.; Stathakis, Sotirios; Zefkili, S.; Mazal, A.; Rosenwald, J.

In: Medical Physics, Vol. 33, No. 6, 2006, p. 2072.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Caneva, S. ; Tsiakalos, M. ; Stathakis, Sotirios ; Zefkili, S. ; Mazal, A. ; Rosenwald, J. / SU‐FF‐T‐102 : Application of the Quality Index Methodology for Dosimetric Verification of Build‐Up Effect Beyond Air‐Tissue Interface in Treatment Planning System Algorithms. In: Medical Physics. 2006 ; Vol. 33, No. 6. pp. 2072.
@article{a22871d301d246568961c3f4aba31f9b,
title = "SU‐FF‐T‐102: Application of the Quality Index Methodology for Dosimetric Verification of Build‐Up Effect Beyond Air‐Tissue Interface in Treatment Planning System Algorithms",
abstract = "Purpose: We have developed and applied a methodology based on quality index (QI) to assess the accuracy of calculations performed on a number of commercial treatment planning systems (TPS) for the case of build‐up effect beyond air‐tissue interfaces. This methodology requires the preliminary constitution of a “reference data set”, obtained experimentally, where correction factors (CF) were calculated as the ratios of the ionization at a depth d beyond the air‐tissue interface to the ionization at the same geometrical point for the reference configuration and for the same number of monitor units. Material and Methods: CFs were obtained from measurements in a phantom that consisted of polystyrene slabs with a 10 cm air‐gap between them. Measurements were performed with a plane parallel ionization chamber at different depths beyond the distal air‐polystyrene interface. They have been repeated with and without the air‐gap at constant source‐detector distance, for a 5×5 cm2 field and for photon energies ranging from 4MV to 23MV and the respective Monte Carlo calculations have been performed the same phantom set‐up. Results: A number of commercial TPS algorithms were tested: users computed CF using basic beam data from their accelerators and these were compared to reference CF for the corresponding QI. Considering that the error in the determination of CF for all beam energies tested should not exceed 6{\%}, at the tested depths only one algorithm calculated CF within this error. The rest of the algorithms overestimated or underestimated CF in the build‐up region. At depth where electronic equilibrium is achieved, results were acceptable for all algorithms. Conclusions: A test that can be easily performed has been designed to validate the calculation algorithm of a TPS for the build‐up effect, using the QI of the incident beam.",
author = "S. Caneva and M. Tsiakalos and Sotirios Stathakis and S. Zefkili and A. Mazal and J. Rosenwald",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.1118/1.2241027",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "33",
pages = "2072",
journal = "Medical Physics",
issn = "0094-2405",
publisher = "AAPM - American Association of Physicists in Medicine",
number = "6",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - SU‐FF‐T‐102

T2 - Application of the Quality Index Methodology for Dosimetric Verification of Build‐Up Effect Beyond Air‐Tissue Interface in Treatment Planning System Algorithms

AU - Caneva, S.

AU - Tsiakalos, M.

AU - Stathakis, Sotirios

AU - Zefkili, S.

AU - Mazal, A.

AU - Rosenwald, J.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - Purpose: We have developed and applied a methodology based on quality index (QI) to assess the accuracy of calculations performed on a number of commercial treatment planning systems (TPS) for the case of build‐up effect beyond air‐tissue interfaces. This methodology requires the preliminary constitution of a “reference data set”, obtained experimentally, where correction factors (CF) were calculated as the ratios of the ionization at a depth d beyond the air‐tissue interface to the ionization at the same geometrical point for the reference configuration and for the same number of monitor units. Material and Methods: CFs were obtained from measurements in a phantom that consisted of polystyrene slabs with a 10 cm air‐gap between them. Measurements were performed with a plane parallel ionization chamber at different depths beyond the distal air‐polystyrene interface. They have been repeated with and without the air‐gap at constant source‐detector distance, for a 5×5 cm2 field and for photon energies ranging from 4MV to 23MV and the respective Monte Carlo calculations have been performed the same phantom set‐up. Results: A number of commercial TPS algorithms were tested: users computed CF using basic beam data from their accelerators and these were compared to reference CF for the corresponding QI. Considering that the error in the determination of CF for all beam energies tested should not exceed 6%, at the tested depths only one algorithm calculated CF within this error. The rest of the algorithms overestimated or underestimated CF in the build‐up region. At depth where electronic equilibrium is achieved, results were acceptable for all algorithms. Conclusions: A test that can be easily performed has been designed to validate the calculation algorithm of a TPS for the build‐up effect, using the QI of the incident beam.

AB - Purpose: We have developed and applied a methodology based on quality index (QI) to assess the accuracy of calculations performed on a number of commercial treatment planning systems (TPS) for the case of build‐up effect beyond air‐tissue interfaces. This methodology requires the preliminary constitution of a “reference data set”, obtained experimentally, where correction factors (CF) were calculated as the ratios of the ionization at a depth d beyond the air‐tissue interface to the ionization at the same geometrical point for the reference configuration and for the same number of monitor units. Material and Methods: CFs were obtained from measurements in a phantom that consisted of polystyrene slabs with a 10 cm air‐gap between them. Measurements were performed with a plane parallel ionization chamber at different depths beyond the distal air‐polystyrene interface. They have been repeated with and without the air‐gap at constant source‐detector distance, for a 5×5 cm2 field and for photon energies ranging from 4MV to 23MV and the respective Monte Carlo calculations have been performed the same phantom set‐up. Results: A number of commercial TPS algorithms were tested: users computed CF using basic beam data from their accelerators and these were compared to reference CF for the corresponding QI. Considering that the error in the determination of CF for all beam energies tested should not exceed 6%, at the tested depths only one algorithm calculated CF within this error. The rest of the algorithms overestimated or underestimated CF in the build‐up region. At depth where electronic equilibrium is achieved, results were acceptable for all algorithms. Conclusions: A test that can be easily performed has been designed to validate the calculation algorithm of a TPS for the build‐up effect, using the QI of the incident beam.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85024820381&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85024820381&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1118/1.2241027

DO - 10.1118/1.2241027

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85024820381

VL - 33

SP - 2072

JO - Medical Physics

JF - Medical Physics

SN - 0094-2405

IS - 6

ER -